Chapter 4 - The Deposition of Lies

Two weeks later.
The conference room at Vance, Sterling & Croft in downtown San Francisco was built entirely of dark mahogany, frosted glass, and brushed brass.
Sitting on one side of the thirty-foot conference table was Arthur Vance, flanked by two junior partners. Beside him sat I, wearing a dark grey suit, my neck and jaw line still covered by a thin, beige silicone pressure garment designed to minimize hypertrophic scarring.
Across the table sat Julian Sterling, his father, Richard Sterling, and two high-priced criminal defense attorneys from one of the most expensive firms in California—lead counsel Robert Hayes.
Vanessa sat between her lawyers.
She looked unrecognizable from the radiant bride at the vineyard. Her blonde hair was pulled into a plain bun, she wore no makeup, and her ivory cashmere had been replaced by a conservative black high-neck blouse meant to make her look modest and remorseful.
Our mother, Eleanor, sat in the corner of the room on a leather chair, her hands clutching a designer handkerchief, dabbing at her eyes every two minutes.
"Let the record reflect," Arthur Vance began, his deep voice carrying flawlessly across the silent room, "that this is a preliminary settlement deposition regarding the civil action of Claire Vance vs. Vanessa Sterling, Chloe Bennett, and The Estate at St. Helena LLC."
Robert Hayes, Vanessa’s lead attorney, cleared his throat, leaning his heavy forearms on the table.
"Arthur," Hayes began in a smooth, persuasive tone. "We are all adults here. What happened at the vineyard was a tragic, foolish, and deeply regrettable accident between two sisters. My client, Vanessa, has already spent forty-eight hours in county custody before her bail hearing. She is deeply traumatized."
I let out a short, quiet breath through my nose.
Vanessa’s head snapped toward me, her eyes flashing with a brief, sharp glint of her old malice before her attorney placed a warning hand on her forearm.
"Traumatized, Mr. Hayes?" Arthur asked, leaning back in his leather chair. "My client spent six days in a specialized burn unit receiving debridement therapy—a process where doctors manually scrub away dead, acid-melted tissue with sterile brushes. She faces eighteen months of physical therapy and potential skin graft surgery."
"We are prepared to offer a full financial resolution," Richard Sterling—Julian’s father—interrupted, his tone sharp and transactional. He pulled a Montblanc pen from his jacket. "The Sterling family is willing to establish a two-hundred-thousand-dollar medical trust to cover all of Claire's out-of-pocket expenses, plus a five-hundred-thousand-dollar personal settlement, provided a full non-disclosure agreement is signed today and all criminal charges are dropped."
Richard set the pen on the table, looking at me as if he had just offered a generous tip to a hotel maid.
"Drop the criminal charges," I repeated softly.
"Yes," Richard said, puffing out his chest. "Vanessa is a young woman with a bright social future. She has charity boards to attend. My son Julian’s career at Sterling Global cannot be tarnished by a public trial involving felony chemical assault charges."
I looked at Richard Sterling. Then I looked at my mother, who was nodding frantically from her chair in the corner.
"Claire, sweetie," Eleanor whimpered, stepping forward from the wall. "Take the money. Please. Think of your sister. A felony conviction will ruin her life! She won't be able to travel to Europe! She’ll be kicked off the Symphony Guild! You've already made your point!"
I stood up slowly.
The room went completely silent.
I reached down, grabbed the bottom edge of the beige silicone pressure garment along my jawline, and gently pulled it back, exposing the raw, raised, purplish-red skin beneath.
Vanessa gasped, looking away instantly. Julian winced, turning his eyes toward the window.
"Look at it, Vanessa," I said, my voice quiet, clear, and unyielding as diamond.
Vanessa kept her head turned.
"LOOK AT ME!" I commanded, my voice booming off the mahogany walls with such terrifying authority that even Richard Sterling jumped in his chair.
Vanessa slowly, hesitantly turned her head. Her eyes locked onto the jagged, discolored scar running from my earlobe down to my throat.
"For twenty-eight years," I said, stepping closer to the table, "you took my clothes. You took my birthday presents. You ruined my high school graduation dinner because you threw a tantrum about your dress. You called me ugly, plain, boring, and useless. And every single time, Mom stood behind you and told me to 'relax' because 'Vanessa is just dramatic.'"
I turned my head toward Eleanor, whose mouth was hanging open.
"You taught her that I was a punching bag, Mom," I told her, my eyes cold and steady. "You taught her that my pain was a joke, my feelings were an inconvenience, and my life was just a backdrop for her spotlight."
I looked back at Vanessa, whose eyes were now welling with genuine, terrified tears.
"You didn't spill champagne, Vanessa," I said. "You poured industrial acid on my face because you couldn't stand the fact that I had fixed a problem you created. You wanted to ruin my skin so I would hide in the corner while you danced."
I picked up the five-hundred-thousand-dollar settlement check Richard Sterling had laid on the table.
I took it in both hands.
RIP.
I tore it cleanly in half.
RIP.
I tore it into four pieces and let them flutter down onto the polished mahogany table like useless white confetti.
"The civil trial is going to court, Mr. Sterling," I said, looking at Richard. "And as for the criminal charges... the State of California does not allow victims to drop felony chemical assault charges once an indictment has been returned by a grand jury."
Vanessa let out a strangled, hysterical sob, grabbing her lawyer’s arm. "Mr. Hayes! Do something! She can't do this!"
Hayes looked at Arthur Vance, then down at his papers, his face completely pale. "Claire... if this goes to a criminal trial, Vanessa is facing mandatory prison time."
May you like
I leaned over the table, looking straight into my sister's terrified, weeping face.
"I know," I whispered smoothly. "Make sure she packs something warm."